BENNY BENCHMARK COMPARES · SMARTWATCHES

Garmin Forerunner 165 vs Venu 4: which Garmin should you choose?

The Garmin Forerunner 165 is a lightweight running watch with an AMOLED screen. The Venu 4 is Garmin's premium smartwatch with a metal case, ECG and torch. Benny sets out what you get for the price difference.

Benny Benchmark · the comparison desk at Megawebshopdeals
Updated on 16 November 2026 · How Benny compares
Best price for runners

Garmin Forerunner 165

39 grams, AMOLED screen, 11 days of battery and all the basic features for running.

from €179at Coolblue, price from the product feed
Most complete

Garmin Venu 4

Metal case, multi-band GPS, ECG, torch, music storage and extensive training analysis.

from €399at Coolblue, price from the product feed

The short answer

The Venu 4 can clearly do more: multi-band GPS, ECG, an LED torch, calls from your wrist, 8 GB of storage with music and training features such as Training Readiness. The Forerunner 165 does the core just as well: a bright AMOLED screen, GPS, heart rate, training suggestions and up to 11 days of battery. And that for less than half the price in our feed.

Choose the Forerunner 165 if…

  • you mainly run and want a light watch;
  • you do not need ECG, a torch or calls via your watch;
  • you take your phone with you for music anyway;
  • you want a good Garmin without paying top price.

Choose the Venu 4 if…

  • you want a watch that also looks good with smart clothes;
  • you run between tall buildings or in the woods and want the most accurate GPS;
  • you want to listen to music and make calls without your phone;
  • you want to dive deep into your recovery and training load;
  • you want to choose from two sizes (41 or 45 mm).
Benny's verdict

Battery life is surprisingly close: 11 versus 12 days. So the difference is not in how long they last, but in what they can do. The Forerunner 165 is the watch I would recommend to most runners: light, clear and complete enough. The Venu 4 is for anyone who wants one watch for sport, health and everyday use, and is willing to pay over €200 extra for that. Do you want music on the Forerunner after all? Then there is a Music version, which costs more.

Specs side by side

Forerunner 165Venu 4
Screen1.2-inch AMOLED, 390 x 3901.4-inch AMOLED, 454 x 454 (45 mm)
Sizes43 mm41 and 45 mm
Weight39 grams56 grams (45 mm, with strap)
Materialplasticstainless steel and plastic
Smartwatch battery lifeup to 11 daysup to 12 days (45 mm), 10 days (41 mm)
GPS battery lifeup to 19 hoursup to 20 hours (45 mm)
Satellite receptionGPS, Glonass, Galileomulti-band with SatIQ
ECGNoYes
LED torchNoYes
Calls from the wristNoYes
Storage and music4 GB; music only on Music version8 GB; Spotify, Deezer, Amazon Music
Garmin PayYesYes
Water resistance5 ATM5 ATM
Price in our feedfrom €179from €399

Highlighted in green = better on that point. Specifications according to the5krunner and inside digital, based on Garmin's figures. Prices from Coolblue's product feed, checked on 16 November 2026.

Benchmarks

These are the battery lives stated by Garmin, as reported by the5krunner. They are not our own measurements. With the always-on display or music the battery drains faster.

Battery life as a smartwatch (days)Garmin's figure, Venu 4 in 45 mm. Higher is better.
Venu 4 (45 mm)12
Forerunner 16511

Source: the5krunner: Garmin Forerunner 165 specificaties, the5krunner: Garmin Venu 4 specificaties

Battery life with GPS (hours)Garmin's figure, GPS only. Higher is better.
Venu 4 (45 mm)20
Forerunner 16519

Source: the5krunner: Garmin Forerunner 165 specificaties, the5krunner: Garmin Venu 4 specificaties

Weight with strap (grams)Lower is better.
Forerunner 16539
Venu 4 (45 mm)56

Source: the5krunner: Garmin Forerunner 165 specificaties, the5krunner: Garmin Venu 4 specificaties

Sport and training

The Forerunner 165 has what a runner needs: daily training suggestions, Garmin Coach plans, a race predictor, wrist-based running power, VO2 max, recovery time, HRV status and Body Battery. A barometric altimeter and compass are in there too.

The Venu 4 goes further. According to DC Rainmaker it has the full training load package, including Training Readiness, plus heat and altitude acclimatisation, triathlon plans and multisport workouts. On top of that comes multi-band GPS, which is more accurate between tall buildings and under trees. The Venu 4 does not have maps.

Health and smart features

Both measure heart rate, blood oxygen saturation and sleep. The Venu 4 adds an ECG app and new sleep features, such as sleep consistency and a smart alarm. It also has an LED torch with white and red light and, according to inside digital, you can make calls from your wrist. The Forerunner 165 cannot do that.

Music is a well-known difference. The standard Forerunner 165 only controls the music on your phone. The Venu 4 stores music from Spotify, Deezer and Amazon Music.

Design and comfort

The Forerunner 165 is made of plastic and weighs 39 grams. You barely feel it while running. The Venu 4 has a stainless steel and plastic case with Gorilla Glass 3 and weighs 56 grams in 45 mm. It looks more premium, but it is heavier. DC Rainmaker notes that the Venu 4 now has only two buttons; the third has gone. Torn between Garmin and Apple? Then read Apple Watch Series 12 vs Garmin Venu 4.

Prices

These are the versions from our product feed, with a direct link to the product page at Dutch online shops. Prices are updated automatically as soon as the shop changes them. Always check the current price at the shop.

If you buy through these links we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. That does not change the verdict. How we make money.

FAQ

What is the difference between the Garmin Forerunner 165 and the Venu 4?

The Venu 4 has a metal case, multi-band GPS, ECG, a torch, music storage and more training analysis. The Forerunner 165 is lighter, simpler and much cheaper.

Which has the longest battery life?

There is little in it. Garmin states up to 11 days for the Forerunner 165 and up to 12 days for the Venu 4 in 45 mm. The Venu 4 in 41 mm manages up to 10 days.

Can I listen to music without my phone?

With the Venu 4 you can. With the Forerunner 165 you need the Music version for that.

Is the Forerunner 165 good enough for running?

Yes. It has GPS, heart rate measurement, training suggestions, a race predictor and wrist-based running power.

Do they work with iPhone and Android?

Yes, both work with iPhone and Android via the Garmin Connect app.

Sources

Benny does not test in a lab himself. Specs come from the manufacturer, measurements from independent testers. These are the sources for this comparison:

Spotted something out of date? Let us know and we'll fix it.