BENNY BENCHMARK COMPARES · SMARTWATCHES

Apple Watch Series 12 vs Garmin Venu 4: which should you buy?

The Apple Watch Series 12 is the most complete smartwatch for iPhone users. The Garmin Venu 4 lasts up to twelve days and is built around sport and recovery. Benny puts them side by side.

Benny Benchmark · the comparison desk at Megawebshopdeals
Updated on 12 November 2026 · How Benny compares
Best smartwatch for iPhone

Apple Watch Series 12

The most apps, the best link with your iPhone and Apple's latest health features. Charge it every day.

from €449recommended retail price, 42 mm aluminium, Wi-Fi only
Best for sport and battery life

Garmin Venu 4

Up to 12 days of battery, accurate multi-band GPS, a built-in torch and works with both iPhone and Android.

from €399at Coolblue on 12 November

The short answer

Do you have an iPhone and mainly want a smart watch for messages, payments, apps and health? Then the Apple Watch Series 12 is the better smartwatch. Do you exercise a lot, want to track your sleep every night without thinking about charging, or have an Android phone? Then the Garmin Venu 4 is the better fit.

Choose the Apple Watch 12 if…

  • you have an iPhone and want messages, calls and apps on your wrist;
  • you want the widest choice of apps and watch faces;
  • you are looking for a light watch: from 32 grams;
  • you don't mind charging every day.

Choose the Garmin Venu 4 if…

  • you only want to charge once or twice a week;
  • you train seriously and want extensive training and recovery data;
  • you have an Android phone: the Apple Watch only works with iPhone;
  • you exercise outdoors a lot and want accurate multi-band GPS;
  • you would find a built-in torch handy.
Benny's verdict

These are two different kinds of watch. The Apple Watch is an extension of your iPhone, the Garmin a sports coach that also shows notifications. Fun detail: during a 50-minute walk with GPS, the Garmin used four times as much battery as the Apple Watch in Tom's Guide's test. Over a whole week the Garmin still wins with ease.

Specs side by side

Apple Watch 12Garmin Venu 4
Case size42 or 46 mm, rectangular41 or 45 mm, round
Weight32 grams (42 mm) / 39.5 grams (46 mm), without strap46 grams (41 mm) / 56 grams (45 mm), with strap
Battery life (manufacturer's figure)Up to 24 hours, 38 hours in low power modeUp to 12 days (45 mm) or 10 days (41 mm); 4 days with always-on
GPSL1Multi-band with SatIQ
Battery life with GPSUp to 10 hours of workoutUp to 20 hours
Works withiPhone onlyiPhone and Android
AppsVery large selection in the App StoreLimited selection
ECGYesYes
Calls via the watchYesYes, with speaker and microphone
TorchNoYes, built-in LED
Pricefrom €449 (recommended retail price)€399 at Coolblue (recommended retail price €549.99)

Highlighted in green = better on that point. Specifications according to Apple, Garmin, Gadgets & Wearables and TechRadar. Prices as of 12 November 2026.

Benchmarks

For battery life we use the manufacturers' figures, converted to hours. Higher is better.

Battery life in normal use (hours)Garmin Venu 4 in 45 mm: 12 days. Apple Watch Series 12: 24 hours.
Garmin Venu 4288
Apple Watch 1224

Source: Gadgets & Wearables: Apple Watch Series 12 vs Garmin Venu 4

Battery life with GPS on (hours)Important for long endurance runs, walks and bike rides.
Garmin Venu 420
Apple Watch 1210

Source: Gadgets & Wearables: Apple Watch Series 12 vs Garmin Venu 4, iCulture: Apple Watch Series 12

Battery: days versus hours

According to Garmin the Venu 4 lasts up to 12 days in the 45 mm version and up to 10 days in the 41 mm version. With the screen always on that is about 4 days. The Apple Watch Series 12 manages 24 hours. That difference determines how you use the watch: you wear the Garmin day and night, the Apple Watch needs a spell on the charger every day. It does charge quickly: according to Apple, a quarter of an hour gives you up to 12 hours again.

Sport and health

Tom's Guide wore both watches during the same walk. The average and maximum heart rate matched exactly, so you don't have to choose on measurement quality. Garmin offers more for people who train: extensive training and recovery data and multi-band GPS. Apple offers the latest health features and alerts, neatly integrated into the Health app on your iPhone.

Smart features

Apple wins here. Replying to messages, paying, navigating, music and thousands of apps: it all works more smoothly on the Apple Watch. The selection of apps for the Venu 4 is small. On the other hand, the Garmin works with both iPhone and Android.

Prices

Below are direct links to the product pages at Dutch online shops. With the Apple Watch, note the difference between Wi-Fi and Cellular. Prices are updated automatically as soon as the shop changes them in its product feed. Always check the current price at the shop.

If you buy through these links we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. That does not change the verdict. How we make money.

FAQ

Does the Garmin Venu 4 work with an iPhone?

Yes. The Venu 4 works with iPhone and Android. The Apple Watch only works with an iPhone.

How long does the Garmin Venu 4's battery last?

According to Garmin up to 12 days (45 mm) or 10 days (41 mm) as a smartwatch, and about 4 days with the screen always on.

Which measures heart rate most accurately?

In Tom's Guide's walking test both gave exactly the same average and maximum heart rate.

Which is better for runners?

The Garmin Venu 4, thanks to the multi-band GPS, the longer battery life with GPS and the more extensive training data.

Which is cheaper?

On 12 November 2026, the Garmin Venu 4: €399 at Coolblue. The Apple Watch Series 12 starts at a recommended retail price of €449.

Sources

Benny does not test in a lab himself. Specs come from the manufacturer, measurements from independent testers. These are the sources for this comparison:

Spotted something out of date? Let us know and we'll fix it.