The short answer
For daily use the Apple Watch Series 12 is the logical choice. It measures the same things, runs the same apps and is not even half the weight. The Ultra 4 is the better choice if you do long endurance sports, are often out of signal range or simply don't want to charge every day.
Choose the Series 12 if…
- you want a light smartwatch that you also wear at night;
- you have slimmer wrists: there is a 42 mm version;
- you mainly track steps, sleep, heart rate and workouts of up to a few hours;
- you don't want to spend more than about €500.
Choose the Ultra 4 if…
- you don't want to charge every day: up to 50 hours versus 24 hours;
- you record long walks, trails, triathlons or bike rides;
- you dive or do a lot of water sports;
- you often go to areas without signal and want an emergency connection via satellite.

This is not a choice between good and better, but between two kinds of use. The Series 12 is a watch you forget you are wearing. The Ultra 4 is a piece of kit. Are you mainly in doubt because of the battery? Bear in mind that the Series 12 has enough charge for half a day again in fifteen minutes.
Specs side by side
| Series 12 | Ultra 4 | |
|---|---|---|
| Case size | 42 or 46 mm | 49 mm |
| Material | Aluminium, titanium or ceramic | Titanium |
| Weight | 32 grams (42 mm) / 39.5 grams (46 mm) | 63 grams |
| Screen | Always-on OLED, up to 2,000 nits | Always-on OLED, up to 3,000 nits |
| Chip | S11 | S11 |
| Battery life (according to Apple) | Up to 24 hours, 38 hours in Low Power Mode | Up to 50 hours, 84 hours in Low Power Mode |
| Workout tracking | Up to 10 hours continuously | Up to 18 hours continuously |
| Fast charging | 80% in about 30 minutes | 80% in about 45 minutes |
| Water resistance | 50 metres, depth app to 6 metres | 100 metres, recreational diving to 40 metres (EN13319) |
| GPS | L1 | Dual frequency (L1 + L5) |
| Satellite connection | No | Yes: SOS and Find My via satellite |
| Siren | No | Yes, audible up to 180 metres |
| Recommended retail price | from €449 (42 mm) / €499 (46 mm) | €899 |
Highlighted in green = better on that point. Specifications and recommended retail prices according to Apple, via iCulture.
Benchmarks
For these two watches no comparable independent measurements from a single test are available yet. That is why Apple's own figures are shown here, which were measured in the same way for both models. Higher is better.
Battery: the biggest difference
According to Apple the Ultra 4 manages up to 50 hours, the Series 12 up to 24 hours. In practice that means: you give the Series 12 a quick charge every day, the Ultra 4 every other day. The Ultra keeps up a workout with GPS for 18 hours, the Series 12 for 10 hours. For a marathon both are enough, for an ultra run or multi-day trek only the Ultra.
The Series 12 does charge faster: according to Apple, in fifteen minutes you have up to 12 hours of use again.
Size and comfort
The Ultra 4 weighs 63 grams and only comes in 49 mm. The 46 mm Series 12 weighs 39.5 grams, the 42 mm just 32 grams. You feel that when sleeping and running. If you have slim wrists, try the Ultra on in a shop first.
Outdoor sports, diving and safety
The Ultra 4 has GPS on two frequencies (L1 and L5). Between tall buildings and in forests that generally gives a more accurate route. It is water resistant to 100 metres and certified for recreational diving to 40 metres. The Series 12 is intended for swimming and snorkelling.
Unique to the Ultra 4 is the satellite connection: without mobile signal or Wi-Fi you can still make an emergency call and share your location. It also has a built-in siren.
Prices
These are the versions Benny recommends, with a direct link to the product page at Dutch online shops. Prices are updated automatically as soon as the shop changes them in its product feed. Note the difference between Wi-Fi and Cellular on the Series 12, and choose the right band size.
If you buy through these links we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. That does not change the verdict. How we make money.
FAQ
Does the Ultra 4 have better health features than the Series 12?
No. Both have the same S11 chip and the same health sensors. The difference is in the battery, case, GPS and the satellite connection.
How long does the Apple Watch Series 12's battery last?
According to Apple, up to 24 hours in normal use and up to 38 hours in Low Power Mode. The Ultra 4 manages up to 50 and 84 hours.
Can I swim with the Apple Watch Series 12?
Yes. The Series 12 is water resistant to 50 metres and suitable for swimming and snorkelling to 6 metres. For diving you need the Ultra 4.
Is the Apple Watch Ultra 4 too big for a slim wrist?
It can be. The case is 49 mm and the watch weighs 63 grams. The Series 12 comes in 42 and 46 mm and is much lighter.
What does the Series 12 cost in titanium?
From €799. That brings you close to the €899 Ultra 4, which is titanium as standard and has a much bigger battery.
Sources
Benny does not test in a lab himself. Specs come from the manufacturer, measurements from independent testers. These are the sources for this comparison:
- iCulture: Apple Watch Series 12 vs Apple Watch Ultra 4
- MacRumors: Apple Watch Series 12 vs. Ultra 4 Buyer's Guide
- Tom's Guide: Apple Watch Series 12 vs Apple Watch Ultra 4
- the5krunner: Apple Watch Ultra 4 vs Series 12
Spotted something out of date? Let us know and we'll fix it.
