BENNY BENCHMARK COMPARES · AUDIO

AirPods 5 vs AirPods Pro 3: which should you buy?

The AirPods 5 have noise cancelling as standard and the same H2 chip as the AirPods Pro 3. The difference is in the fit, the strength of the noise cancelling, the battery and the health features.

Benny Benchmark · the comparison desk at Megawebshopdeals
Updated on 12 November 2026 · How Benny compares
Best value for money

Apple AirPods 5

Open fit without silicone tips, noise cancelling and Live Translation for a low price.

from €139at Coolblue on 12 November
Best sound and noise cancelling

Apple AirPods Pro 3

Silicone tips that seal, much stronger noise cancelling, 8 hours of battery and heart rate monitoring.

from €210at bol on 12 November

The short answer

Tom's Guide gives the AirPods Pro 3 an 88 and the AirPods 5 a 77. The Pro 3 is better on sound, noise cancelling and battery life. The AirPods 5 are the better buy if you don't want tips in your ears or want to spend as little as possible and still want noise cancelling.

Choose the AirPods 5 if…

  • you find silicone tips uncomfortable and want an open fit;
  • you mainly make calls, listen to podcasts and occasionally music;
  • you want to keep hearing something of your surroundings, for example on the bike;
  • you want to spend around €150.

Choose the AirPods Pro 3 if…

  • you are often on the train, on a plane or in a busy open-plan office;
  • sound quality is important to you;
  • you listen for long stretches: 8 hours versus 4 to 5 hours;
  • you exercise and want to measure your heart rate without an Apple Watch;
  • you want to use the hearing features.
Benny's verdict

Noise cancelling in earbuds without sealing tips remains a compromise: it dampens, but doesn't seal. If you travel a lot, you hear the difference from the Pro 3 straight away. If you mainly listen at home or in the office and find tips annoying, the AirPods 5 are a very good deal. In that case do get the version with the wireless charging case: it lasts an hour longer and has the volume control on the stem.

Specs side by side

AirPods 5AirPods Pro 3
FitOpen, without tipsSilicone tips that seal
ChipH2H2
Noise cancellingYesYes, much stronger thanks to the sealing tips
Battery life with noise cancelling4 hours (5 hours with wireless charging case)8 hours
Water and dust resistanceIP57IP57
Live TranslationYesYes
Heart rate monitoringNoYes
Hearing featuresNoYes
Volume control on the stemOnly on the version with wireless charging caseYes
Tom's Guide score77 out of 10088 out of 100
Price€139 / €159 at Coolblue€210 at bol

Highlighted in green = better on that point. Specifications according to Apple, via Tom's Guide, Gizmodo and T3. Prices as of 12 November 2026.

Benchmarks

The battery life is Apple's figure with noise cancelling on. The overall score comes from Tom's Guide's comparative test. Higher is better.

Battery life with noise cancelling (hours, Apple's figure)Per charge of the earbuds themselves, without topping up in the case.
AirPods Pro 38
AirPods 5 with wireless charging case5
AirPods 54

Source: Tom's Guide: AirPods 5 vs AirPods Pro 3

Tom's Guide overall score (out of 100)Price, design, sound, noise cancelling, calls and battery combined.
AirPods Pro 388
AirPods 577

Source: Tom's Guide: AirPods 5 vs AirPods Pro 3

Fit: open or sealed

This is the most important difference. The AirPods 5 sit loosely in your ear, without a tip. That feels airy and you keep hearing something of your surroundings. The AirPods Pro 3 have silicone tips in several sizes that seal the ear. That gives more bass, better noise cancelling and a firmer hold during exercise, but not everyone finds it comfortable.

Noise cancelling and sound

Both have active noise cancelling. On the AirPods 5 it is, according to Apple, up to 50% better than on the previous generation and, according to Tom's Guide, decent for open earbuds. It is no match for the sealing Pro 3. On sound the Pro 3 clearly wins too; the tester counts them among the best-sounding wireless earbuds. For calls it is a draw.

Battery and extra features

The Pro 3 plays for 8 hours with noise cancelling on, the AirPods 5 for 4 hours, or 5 hours on the version with the wireless charging case. The Pro 3 also measures your heart rate during exercise and has hearing features. Live Translation is on both.

Prices

Below are direct links to the product pages at Dutch online shops. With the AirPods 5, pay attention to the version: with or without wireless charging case. Prices are updated automatically as soon as the shop changes them in its product feed. Always check the current price at the shop.

If you buy through these links we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. That does not change the verdict. How we make money.

FAQ

Do the AirPods 5 have noise cancelling?

Yes, both versions of the AirPods 5 have active noise cancelling. It is less strong than on the AirPods Pro 3, because the AirPods 5 don't seal the ear.

What is the difference between the two versions of the AirPods 5?

The more expensive version has a wireless charging case, a volume control on the stem and lasts an hour longer with noise cancelling on.

How long do they last?

With noise cancelling on: AirPods 5 4 to 5 hours, AirPods Pro 3 8 hours per charge.

Can the AirPods Pro 3 measure your heart rate?

Yes. The AirPods Pro 3 have a heart rate sensor. The AirPods 5 don't.

Are they water resistant?

Both have an IP57 rating and can cope with sweat and rain.

Sources

Benny does not test in a lab himself. Specs come from the manufacturer, measurements from independent testers. These are the sources for this comparison:

Spotted something out of date? Let us know and we'll fix it.